TV Ramblings…
It’s been a while and things are building up. Heck, many of them have built up and long since escaped me. This time, it’s TV…
#1. Stargate Universe
Before it came out, I was heavily against it. I was upset that they’d cancelled Atlantis, which was possibly one of the best sci-fi shows in a long time. In the end though, I was willing to give it a chance. There’s too little good sci-fi on TV to not give it that much.
Sadly, I was right in the first place. This iteration of the franchise has been retooled (good word, vaguely implies the creators are tools) to appeal to an audience it’s not supposed to appeal to. Who’s that? Well, they’re going after the younger demographic and I think they’re trying to pull in more chicks as well. Sad.
In the end, what did we get? Well, it’s a show based on a space ship. One that can’t be controlled by our cast and is usually out of something (power, water, ideas, plots, etc). Most of the characters are boring sacks of skin who are more interested in the petty concept that they can’t get back home rather than the life that is in front of them, or the million year old ship that surrounds them. Rush (played by Robert Carlyle) is the only truly interesting character.
We’ve got a replacement character for David MacKay from Atlantis in Eli Wallace (played by David Blue). He comes off more as a “Seth Rogen in space” but without the fun. He also can’t really seem to figure much of anything. Instead, he’s constantly hanging around with the shipboard slut, Chloe Armstrong. There’s some major crushing going on there. Occasionally he’s thinking about her, while she’s off somewhere else in the ship fucking some guy in a closet. It’s kinda sad. According to Wikipedia, he’s supposed to be “Matt Damon’s character from Good Will Hunting with a little Jack Black thrown in.” Except that those characters get the girl.
Which sort of brings me to the indiscriminate love scenes that are peppered around various episodes. No rhyme or reason, no relevance to the plot.. they just pop up occasionally for no apparent reason. They’re not particularly hot either.
Add all of this together with the fact that they rarely turn the lights on, the cameraman is the same noob they had for BSG who can’t seem to hold the camera still and that we’re 9 episodes in now and haven’t met (or even heard a passing mention of) a single alien or race – and what have you got? Well, not much. Stargate Universe. Congrats, you’ve escaped science fiction and now you’re left with… just fiction.
I wish that the creators of the show and the people at SyFy would just come to grips with their lot in life and accept it. You can’t have a sci-fi show with the numbers of Gossip Girl. You’re a specialty channel. That means specializing, not generalizing. If you want to make boring, tedious soapy teen melodrama – GO WORK SOMEWHERE ELSE.
PS. Lou Diamond Phillips – you were much more likable at the tables of the World Series of Poker than you are on this show.
#2. Defying Gravity
Sadly, this show has been cancelled. It was great though, trust me. And Peter from Office Space made a good “guy-in-charge” spaceman. It’s funny, because before the show came out, someone called it “Greys Anatomy in Space” (presumably because the creators worked on that show, and they said this was a character drama that just happened to be set in space). In the end though, this show was 10x more sci-fi in it’s first 9 episodes than SGU has managed. The acting was stellar, the effects were great and it wasn’t boring.
#3. Eastwick
Also cancelled. Yet, the show airing before it, the truly sub-par Cougars with Courtney Cox was picked up. Eastwick was an excellent TV adaptation of the movie/book and the acting was great. The three actresses they picked for the women were stellar in the roles (including Rebecca Romjin) and Paul Gross was intriguing as Darryl Van Horne. Gross didn’t ham it up too much, and wasn’t over the top given the previous iteration portrayed by (the always over-the-top) Jack Nicholson.
#4. Dollhouse
Cancelled. I didn’t watch it, but given the large body of truly pedestrian crap that Joss Whedon has bestowed upon us in the past, I’m not surprised. Frankly, the only surprising thing is that it lasted into a second season. I’ll never forgive him for that hot mess he called Buffy the TV series, nor the truly ghastly script he wrote for Alien 4 that pretty much put the final nail the franchise’s proverbial coffin.
#5. Fringe
This is getting to be the best sci-fi that TV has to offer, at least, until JJ Abrams other vehicle, Lost, pulls into the lot. It meanders a bit here and there, but overall the script quality is high, the acting and effects are good. Did I mention it has Spock? Sorry – yeah, it’s got Spock! He lives in another dimension, but that doesn’t diminish the coolness. Watch this show.
#6. Sanctuary
For a show done on a shoestring budget with all virtual sets, they’re not doing bad at all. Some of the things they’ve done seemed a bit odd, but in the end, most worked out well. They killed off a major character in S2, a good one too – I’m still up in the air about that one. It was abrupt and seemingly pointless. Overall, it’s a great little show. Kudos, Amanda Tapping.
#7. South Park
Up to season what, 45? Still funny, still irreverent and relevant. Amazing.

